Bar Economics
Let me tell you about how I spent Valentine's Day 2008. I was at John Harvard's with a smart, platonic friend (I have to say platonic because of the day it was). She designs airplane engines. I design guidance software. We were talking about engineering-type work.
At some point, a guy sitting adjacent from us chimed in and asked if we were engineers. He seemed interesting. He had some opinions on production and running businesses. It turned out he was visiting Harvard from Houston for a conference on energy. We talked a little bit about politics and the upcoming election, then the conversation turned economic in nature. The gentleman we were with was decidedly over 50 years of age, and it seemed like he was interested in our 25 year old opinion. Meanwhile, we were interested in his thoughts. The stimulating exchange of ideas was quite pleasant.
However, after 30-45 minutes, the conversation became uncomfortably ideological and it was clear that his ideology was quite dissimilar to my ideology. One specific question he framed was, "Who do you trust more, government or business?" I thought about it, and the true answer was "neither". I said that both are prone to screw things up, but with further reflection I can say that I trust government more. He argued that businesses were the trustworthy ones and cited the government as having a monopoly within the country. A monopoly that made it impossible for businesses to compete in certain ways... more on that later. He also wasn't happy with the way government spent his tax dollars. I would tend to agree, but I'm at the top of the welfare support system in this country as a beneficiary of 3+ years of software engineering work for various projects sponsored by the national defense budget.
He made one clever point that can be summed up in a tabular format.
Essencially, his distrust in government boiled down to his feeling that they fit into the "Spending somebody else's money on somebody else" camp. He started preaching negatively about government and in particular, income tax. He basically told us public schools are horrible in Texas, and he was griping about having to send his semi-dyslexic fourth grader to a private school because the public schools didn't have programs to get through to the boy. He was upset that every six weeks his maids would quit so that they could go collect unemployment. But yeah, he was really, really ticked off at the IRS. He said that his tax bill was $2.2 M on $400k of earnings. That made him want to leave the country because his view was that the government was wasting all the tax money he was paying. Thusly, I met an upper class slob who is in the market to relocate his under-performing business to Dubai.
His business, by the way, is apparently in the energy industry. You can check them out if you want. It turns out that he is the first guy under the "Leadership" page. So, part of his gripe is that energy (gas and electric) is regulated in a way that makes competition hard for company's in the industry (think Enron). He thinks the regulations stifle innovation in a way that yields power generation inefficiencies that are no higher than they were when Edison opened the world's first power plant in Downtown Manhattan (which he claimed was 30% efficiency). He advocates making use of the heat that is a product of the process to convert energy into a usable format, instead of letting it go to waste. In theory and practice, his logic is sound. But he was upset with the way the industry is structured so that their is no incentive for increases in efficiencies, because of the way the government collects taxes on additional revenue and so it isn't worth it to the industry to work twice as hard for the marginal increase in profits. And he complained about the public monopoly on education. He said there was no incentive for schools in Texas to have a program for his semi-dyslexic son, and they were much happier having him pull the kid out and sending him to a private school that could give him the attention he needed. I think that is more of a statement on Texas schools then the nation as a whole (my local high school certainly had special needs programs).
All-in-all I had a unique and interesting conversation, despite the fact that by the end I wanted nothing more than to get the hell out of there to get away from the lecture that I mostly disagreed with.
At some point, a guy sitting adjacent from us chimed in and asked if we were engineers. He seemed interesting. He had some opinions on production and running businesses. It turned out he was visiting Harvard from Houston for a conference on energy. We talked a little bit about politics and the upcoming election, then the conversation turned economic in nature. The gentleman we were with was decidedly over 50 years of age, and it seemed like he was interested in our 25 year old opinion. Meanwhile, we were interested in his thoughts. The stimulating exchange of ideas was quite pleasant.
However, after 30-45 minutes, the conversation became uncomfortably ideological and it was clear that his ideology was quite dissimilar to my ideology. One specific question he framed was, "Who do you trust more, government or business?" I thought about it, and the true answer was "neither". I said that both are prone to screw things up, but with further reflection I can say that I trust government more. He argued that businesses were the trustworthy ones and cited the government as having a monopoly within the country. A monopoly that made it impossible for businesses to compete in certain ways... more on that later. He also wasn't happy with the way government spent his tax dollars. I would tend to agree, but I'm at the top of the welfare support system in this country as a beneficiary of 3+ years of software engineering work for various projects sponsored by the national defense budget.
He made one clever point that can be summed up in a tabular format.
| On A Product For Me | For Somebody Else | |
|---|---|---|
| Spending My Money | Quality is high, Price is low | Quality is low, Price is low |
| Somebody Else's Money | Quality is high, Price is high | Quality is low, Price is high |
Essencially, his distrust in government boiled down to his feeling that they fit into the "Spending somebody else's money on somebody else" camp. He started preaching negatively about government and in particular, income tax. He basically told us public schools are horrible in Texas, and he was griping about having to send his semi-dyslexic fourth grader to a private school because the public schools didn't have programs to get through to the boy. He was upset that every six weeks his maids would quit so that they could go collect unemployment. But yeah, he was really, really ticked off at the IRS. He said that his tax bill was $2.2 M on $400k of earnings. That made him want to leave the country because his view was that the government was wasting all the tax money he was paying. Thusly, I met an upper class slob who is in the market to relocate his under-performing business to Dubai.
His business, by the way, is apparently in the energy industry. You can check them out if you want. It turns out that he is the first guy under the "Leadership" page. So, part of his gripe is that energy (gas and electric) is regulated in a way that makes competition hard for company's in the industry (think Enron). He thinks the regulations stifle innovation in a way that yields power generation inefficiencies that are no higher than they were when Edison opened the world's first power plant in Downtown Manhattan (which he claimed was 30% efficiency). He advocates making use of the heat that is a product of the process to convert energy into a usable format, instead of letting it go to waste. In theory and practice, his logic is sound. But he was upset with the way the industry is structured so that their is no incentive for increases in efficiencies, because of the way the government collects taxes on additional revenue and so it isn't worth it to the industry to work twice as hard for the marginal increase in profits. And he complained about the public monopoly on education. He said there was no incentive for schools in Texas to have a program for his semi-dyslexic son, and they were much happier having him pull the kid out and sending him to a private school that could give him the attention he needed. I think that is more of a statement on Texas schools then the nation as a whole (my local high school certainly had special needs programs).
All-in-all I had a unique and interesting conversation, despite the fact that by the end I wanted nothing more than to get the hell out of there to get away from the lecture that I mostly disagreed with.